The Double Life of Samuel Cross

The body was found at 7:14 AM on a Thursday in November. By 8:30, the neighbors had already decided she'd overdosed. By noon, the police had decided the same thing. By evening, Detective Rebecca Torres had decided that everyone who'd decided that was wrong.

The victim was a woman named Iris Chen. Thirty-one years old. Jazz singer at a club called the Velvet Room in Hell's Kitchen. Found in her apartment on a third-floor walk-up in Harlem, lying on her bed, fully dressed, eyes open, expression not of pain but of something else — recognition, maybe. Or relief. Torres couldn't tell which.

"What about the glass?" her partner asked.

"On the nightstand. Empty. Smells like whiskey."

"Toxicology?"

"Still running. But I checked the bottle — it's a cheap brand. She could afford better. If she wanted to kill herself, she'd use something she likes."

"Or something easy to get."

Torres looked at the body again. Iris Chen's hand was curled inward, like she'd been holding something. Torres asked the coroner to check. Inside the palm, wrapped in a thin layer of skin, was a tiny piece of paper.

"A note?" her partner asked.

"No. A receipt. From a liquor store on 125th Street. Dated three days ago. Time: 9:42 PM."

"Three days before she died?"

"Three days before. So she bought the whiskey three days before she used it. That's not the behavior of someone planning to kill herself."

Torres filed the report and went to her desk and sat down and thought about the third death.

The first was a woman named Sandra Wu. Twenty-eight. Found in her apartment in Astoria. Official cause: heart attack. The second was a man named Daniel Reeves. Thirty-five. Found in his office in Midtown. Official cause: stroke. Neither had been friends with Iris Chen. None of the three had known each other.

But they'd all been patients of the same doctor.

Dr. Samuel Cross.

Torres had found the connection by accident. She'd been looking up Iris Chen's medical records — her health insurance covered a visit to a "Cross, Samuel MD, Psychotherapy and Psychiatry" six weeks before her death. And Sandra Wu's records showed a visit to the same address eight weeks before. And Daniel Reeves' — three months before.

She went to the address. It was a glass building in Midtown, forty floors up, with a receptionist who smiled too much and a waiting room that looked like a hotel lobby.

Dr. Cross's office was on the forty-second floor. It was exactly what Torres expected from a man who published books and gave TED Talks: minimalist, expensive, calm. The walls were white. The furniture was grey. The view was Manhattan at dusk, and it made everything look like it was happening underwater.

Dr. Cross himself was forty-eight, distinguished, and completely disarming. He had the kind of face that made people trust him — lined around the eyes from smiling, a mouth that looked like it knew how to deliver bad news gently, hair that was grey in exactly the right places.

"Detective Torres," he said, extending his hand. His grip was firm but not too firm. "Thank you for coming."

"I have a few questions about your patients."

"Of course. I'll do my best to help. Though I should mention — patient confidentiality limits what I can share."

"Of course."

They sat. He poured her a glass of water. She didn't drink it.

"Three of your patients have died in the past eighteen months," she said. "All from apparently natural causes. Is that correct?"

"Unfortunately, yes. I'm deeply saddened by all three losses."

"Did you treat them for the same condition?"

"Similar conditions. All related to trauma. Dissociative disorders, particularly."

"Dissociative disorders."

"Difficulty distinguishing between internal and external reality. Dream states intruding into waking life. It's more common than people think."

"Did any of them mention dreams about a garden?"

Dr. Cross's expression didn't change. But Torres noticed something — a flicker in his eyes. So fast that if she hadn't been watching for it, she would have missed it.

"A garden," he repeated. "That's an interesting detail. Where did you hear about that?"

"I'm curious why you find it interesting, Doctor."

He smiled. It was a good smile. The kind of smile that had won juries, cured patients, and filled lecture halls. "Because it's unusual. Patients with dissociative disorders often have very specific imagery. A garden is not common. It suggests a particular type of repressed memory — usually related to childhood, safety, and loss."

"What kind of childhood memory?"

"I'd rather not speculate without speaking to the patients directly."

"Right. Well, one of the patients — Iris Chen — mentioned a garden in a note she left behind. We found it in her possession."

"Iris was a talented artist," Dr. Cross said. "And a remarkable singer. Her death is a genuine loss."

"Did she seem... stable?" Torres asked. "In her final sessions?"

Dr. Cross paused. Just a fraction of a second. Then: "Iris was making progress. She was learning to distinguish between dream and reality. I was optimistic about her recovery."

"You were optimistic."

"Yes."

"Until she died."

"Nothing in medicine is certain, Detective."

Torres finished her water. It was cold and tasteless. "One more question, Doctor. Did any of your patients ever mention you — personally? Something about your personal life? Your past?"

Dr. Cross's smile didn't waver. "Patients sometimes share personal information as part of the therapeutic process. I take confidentiality very seriously."

"Of course." She stood. "Thank you for your time, Doctor."

She walked out of his office and down the forty-two floors and out of the building and into the November air, and she had two choices: believe the story of the distinguished doctor who had lost three patients and was grieving, or follow the thread of the garden and the receipt and the dead woman's hand, and find out what happened in those sessions.

She chose neither. She chose both.

That night, a woman walked into Dr. Cross's office at six in the evening, after hours. She was twenty-six, from Queens, wearing a paint-splattered jacket and carrying a bag that contained canvases and brushes and a note from a jazz singer's neighbor.

"Dr. Cross?" she said to the receptionist. "I'm here to see him. His name is Samuel. I know him."

The receptionist smiled too much. "Dr. Cross doesn't see patients after six."

"I'm not a patient."

"Then I'm afraid —"

"Tell him it's Ava Mercer. Tell him I'm the eighth one."

The receptionist's smile stopped. She picked up the phone.

Five minutes later, a man appeared in the doorway of the inner office. Dr. Cross. Looking at her with an expression she couldn't read. Not surprise. Not fear. Something in between.

"Ava Mercer," he said. "Come in."

She followed him into his office. It was exactly what she'd expected — white walls, grey furniture, Manhattan through the window. And on the desk, a photograph of a woman she didn't recognize, framed and facing forward.

"You know who I am," Dr. Cross said, sitting down.

"I know your name. I know your patients have been dying. I know about the garden."

He was quiet for a moment. Then: "Where did you hear about the garden?"

"A singer named Iris Chen. She was your patient. She died three days ago. Her neighbor told me that Iris talked about a garden before she died. And she told me to find you and tell you I was the eighth one."

"The eighth what?"

"The eighth person who's been in your dream."

Dr. Cross set his hands flat on the desk. His fingers were long and well-manicured, and for a moment, Torres — who had seen the photograph later — understood why people trusted him. He looked like a man who had never told a lie in his life.

"Ava," he said gently. "I think there's been a misunderstanding. I'm a psychoanalyst. I don't let people into my dreams."

"She said you do."

"Who is she?"

"Ava Mercer. I'm Ava Mercer."

He looked at her for a long time. Then he stood, walked to the window, and looked out at Manhattan. The city was lit up — yellow and white and amber — and from that height, it looked peaceful.

"My first patient," he said, still facing the window, "was a woman named Evelyn Marsh. She was a nurse in World War I. She had dreams about a garden. A real garden, in Boston, where she used to live as a child. Her mother had planted it. Her mother died, and the garden died with her, and Evelyn carried it in her dreams for the rest of her life."

Torres said nothing.

"I tried to help her," Dr. Cross continued. "I used hypnosis — deep hypnosis, the kind that's not recommended anymore. And something went wrong. She went deeper than I expected, and she saw something she wasn't ready to see, and —" He turned around. His face was different. The smile was gone. The lines around his eyes looked like scars. "She died. Three days later."

"I know," Torres said.

"You know?"

"She was your first. Sandra Wu was the second. Daniel Reeves was the third. And Iris Chen — Iris was the fourth."

Dr. Cross sat back down. He looked old. Not forty-eight old. Seventy-eight old.

"I didn't kill them," he said. "I can swear to that. They died naturally. Or they seemed to. But I — I opened something in them. Something that was locked for a reason. And I can't close it again."

"Then why do you keep doing it?"

"Because I don't know how to stop."

Ava Mercer stood in the middle of the office and thought about the garden. She thought about the dreams she'd been having — not her dreams, someone else's. A garden that kept growing and being destroyed and growing again. And a man at the center of it, planting seeds, knowing the ice was coming, planting anyway.

"I can see it," she said quietly. "The garden. I've been seeing it for months. I don't know how. I just — I close my eyes and I'm there. And I can see him. The man. He's planting. And he's sad. And he's alone."

Dr. Cross put his face in his hands. When he took it away, his eyes were wet.

"Every night," he said. "I dream about the garden. And every night, I plant something new. And every night, it dies. And I plant again."

"What are you planting?"

"Memories. The memories of the people I've lost. Evelyn. Sandra. Daniel. Iris. I plant them in the garden so they don't disappear. Because if I stop planting, they're gone. And I can't let them be gone."

Ava Mercer walked out of Dr. Cross's office at midnight. She walked to the subway and rode it to Queens and went home and looked at her canvases and didn't paint. She lay in bed and closed her eyes and was in the garden.

The flowers were yellow. The boy was planting. And behind the wall, she could see a door. And behind the door, she could see a room, and in the room, a man sitting at a desk, his head in his hands, planting seeds in the dark.

She opened her eyes. It was morning. The garden was gone. But the door was still there, behind the wall, and she knew, with a certainty that had nothing to do with dreams, that one day she would open it.

And when she did, she didn't know what she'd find. But she knew it wouldn't be what she expected.

---