The Useless Ground
The funeral was small, which is what Richard Hall would have wanted if he had ever wanted anything about his own funeral. Three children attended: David, who couldn't stop checking his phone; Susan, who cried for exactly twenty minutes and then wiped her face with the efficient precision of someone who had planned her tears in advance; and Mark, who stood at the back of the cemetery and smoked a cigarette despite the sign that said NO SMOKING.
They had come to bury their father. They had also come, implicitly, to bury the idea of him. Richard Hall had been a real estate developer—mid-tier, neither spectacularly successful nor notably failing. He had made enough money to buy a house in Scarsdale and a boat he rarely used and a burial plot in Cedar Hill Cemetery that cost more than most people's cars. He had spent the last fifteen years of his life obsessed with the idea that the ground his family rested upon would somehow give his grandchildren an advantage in a world that was rapidly running out of advantages for anyone.
"Your grandfather was a practical man," David told the cemetery attendant, who was drilling holes into the ground for three new plots adjacent to Richard's. "He believed that physical things—properties, locations, the right address—had power. He thought the right cemetery, the right elevation, the right neighborhood for the dead would translate into the right opportunities for the living."
The attendant, whose name tag read MANOJ, nodded without looking up. "A lot of people buy plots for that reason," he said. "It's tradition."
"Not tradition," David corrected. "Superstition with a price tag."
Richard Hall's cemetery choice had been deliberate. Cedar Hill sat on a bluff overlooking the Hudson River, with a view that was visible from several high-rise buildings in Manhattan. When Richard had first walked the grounds with a sales representative—a woman with a clipboard and a practiced smile—he had been struck by the prospect of his name on a headstone with that view behind it. It was, he had told his children at the time, the kind of ground that said: this family mattered.
Susan had rolled her eyes. Dad, you're buying a cemetery plot. You're not buying a trophy.
But Richard had bought three plots: one for himself, one for Susan (against the day), and one for David, who at forty-two still lived in a studio apartment in Brooklyn and sent his father passive-aggressive emails about emotional availability.
The irony, which no one mentioned at the funeral, was that Richard's obsession with the ground his family would rest upon had been directly responsible for the estrangement that now left him lying six feet deep in soil he had paid twelve thousand dollars for. He had missed David's wedding because he was inspecting headstone samples. He had not spoken to Mark in three years because Mark had refused to participate in what he called the Hall Family Burial Negotiations—a spreadsheet that Richard had printed and distributed at Thanksgiving, ranking potential plot locations by projected property value appreciation and proximity to other prominent family members.
Mark had left the table. David had picked up his phone. Susan had eaten her roast beef in silence.
Now they stood by the open grave—Richard's grave, already dug, already waiting—and watched as the casket was lowered. David's phone buzzed with an email from his boss. Susan adjusted her sunglasses. Mark finished his cigarette and dropped it on the ground, then picked it up again because even at his father's funeral he couldn't bring himself to litter.
After the service, after the flowers were arranged and the last well-wisher had driven away and the three Hall children were alone with the fresh mound of earth, something unexpected happened. They started talking.
Not about their father. Not about the funeral. But about the cemetery itself.
"Do you know how many people are buried under this bluff?" Susan asked, looking out at the Hudson.
"Thousands," Mark said.
"Thousands of people who paid for this view," Susan continued. "Thousands of people who thought the right ground would make a difference. And now they're all here, under the same dirt, looking at the same river, and none of them can do anything about it."
David knelt down and pressed his hand into the fresh earth. It was warm, recently turned. "I always thought the point was the ground," he said quietly. "That if we could just get the right house, the right school, the right zip code, the right everything. But it's just dirt. It's all just dirt."
Mark looked at his brother. He looked at his sister. He looked at the grave. For the first time in years, he felt something that wasn't annoyance or exhaustion or the particular numbness that came from carrying a family history that felt like a debt you never signed up for.
He felt nothing. And that nothing, in that moment, under the wide gray sky above Cedar Hill Cemetery, was the most honest thing any of them had felt in a very long time.
Years later, a homeless man named Eugene Torres died in a shelter in the Bronx. He had no next of kin. The city arranged for his burial in a plot at Pine Ridge Cemetery, several towns north of Cedar Hill, in a section where the grass was overgrown and the headstones listed dates from the 1940s and before. Eugene Torres was buried in a pauper's grave, in a plain pine box, with no headstone and no service and no one to visit.
His son, a boy of fifteen who had been taken into foster care at age six and had spent the intervening nine years moving between families who loved him as well as they could, learned about his father's death from a social worker. He drove to Pine Ridge Cemetery on a Saturday morning, found the section where Eugene was buried, and stood there for a long time looking at the flat marker that read IN GOD WE TRUST—PAUPER'S PLOT 47B.
He did not cry. He did not feel anything that could be named. He simply stood there in the quiet of the overgrown cemetery, surrounded by the useless ground of people who had tried and failed and succeeded and been forgotten, and he understood, with a clarity that would stay with him for the rest of his life, that the earth does not discriminate. The ground receives everyone equally. It is the only truly democratic thing in a world that has invented almost nothing else of the kind.
He left the cemetery without marking the grave. He walked back to his apartment in Harlem, took a book off his shelf—a book about urban planning—and began to read.
--- OTMES v2.0 Objective Tensor Encoding --- Code: OTMES-v2-98E136CC-15.9-M2-66.8-300R50005000-2370 E_total: 15.88 Dominant Mode: M2 (Satire) N-Active: 0.3, N-Passive: 0.7 K-Individual: 0.5, K-Superindividual: 0.5 M-vector: [5.0, 3.0, 10.0, 9.5, 3.0, 2.0, 3.0, 0.0, 1.0, 2.0] ---
Based on the pending patent application document (202610351844.3), creationstamp.com has calculated the tensor feature encoding of this article:
OTMES-v2-UNKNOWN
- Art
- Causes
- Crafts
- Dance
- Drinks
- Film
- Fitness
- Food
- Games
- Gardening
- Health
- Home
- Literature
- Music
- Networking
- Other
- Party
- Religion
- Shopping
- Sports
- Theater
- Wellness